|
Valuation
of Archaeological Artefacts
It
happens sometimes on our explorations off the beaten track
that participants find archaeological artefacts themselves
by coincidence, or people in the local communities we
visit offer such objects for sale. Other participants may
bring archaeological artefacts that they have found,
bought or otherwise acquired during their stay in Mexico
with them to our anthropologists or archaeologists and ask
for a commercial valuation of them. When this occurs, it
is an unpleasant situation for all of us, and we therefore
would like to say right away that we are not under any
circumstances providing such information. If such objects
are found during our exploration, and we are able to
identify them, we may give an opinion on their age or
significance, but that's it.
It
is forbidden by law to sell antiquities or to take them
out of the country. It is also a serious crime according
to Mexican and International Law to excavate an
archaeological site on your own without appropriate
permissions from the National Institute of History and
Anthropology (INAH). This is the case even if you decided
to dig for antiquities in your own garden. If you find an
object by coincidence, please hand it in to an appropriate
instance, a local museum or the local INAH department. If
possible, you should leave it exactly where you found it.
When such objects are removed from their site of origin,
and end up in a private collection without any
documentation about the context in which it was found, it
is a loss for science, and a loss for humanity.
It
is almost impossible for a private collector to have a
legal collection of pre-Hispanic Mexican artefacts. Some
artefacts that were brought home by the Spanish
conquistadors in the 16th century entered European markets
and found their ways into private collections and museums.
If you possess one of these objects, it is technically
legal (even though few 16th century Spaniards obtained the
exotic and often valuable artefacts that they sent home in
a way that we would consider morally acceptable today...).
Almost all other pre-Hispanic Mesoamerican objects that
can be found in private collections today are looted, or
were excavated illegally and left Mexico illegally. That
also is the case for exotic items that your great-great
grandfather may have brought home from a trip to Mexico in
the 19th century or so...
From
the “Principles of Archaeological Ethics” of the
Society for American Archaeology:
"Principle No. 3: Commercialization. The
Society for American Archaeology has long recognized that
the buying and selling of objects out of archaeological
context is contributing to the destruction of the
archaeological record on the American continents and
around the world. The commercialization of archaeological
objects—their use as commodities to be exploited for
personal enjoyment or profit—results in the destruction
of archaeological sites and of contextual information that
is essential to understanding the archaeological record.
Archaeologists should therefore carefully weigh the
benefits to scholarship of a project against the costs of
potentially enhancing the commercial value of
archaeological objects. Whenever possible they should
discourage, and should themselves avoid, activities that
enhance the commercial value of archaeological objects,
especially objects that are not curated in public
institutions, or readily available for scientific study,
public interpretation, and display.”
|
|